Nick Routledge@nick_routledge
Repost

RT @nick_routledge: @jesuits_ireland @Pontifex 4/ Our present modernity can be characterized by its endless deferral of judgment, “a secularized parody of the Church’s incessant deferral of the last judgment” (Agamben), an institution that can only preserve its own existence by endlessly postponing the judgment it announces.

“The crises...that the governments of the world continually proclaim” become “states of permanent exception and emergency,” and a permanent state of exception is, of course, no longer exceptional. Crisis is normalized and, in consequence, loses what was formerly its preeminent characteristic. Once, crisis meant a critical or decisive stage in a course of events—a day of judgment—that must lead to a resolution. A crisis in an illness, for example, was the moment at which a definitive turn toward life or death, improvement or worsening could be expected…Our world is in perpetual crisis, a crisis that never resolves, “no crisis at all,” because resolving it would end the game. Crisis is “our normal state,” the consequence of never allowing a final judgment to be reached.
Image description

Original X alt text

“The crises...that the governments of the world continually proclaim” become “states of permanent exception and emergency,” and a permanent state of exception is, of course, no longer exceptional. Crisis is normalized and, in consequence, loses what was formerly its preeminent characteristic. Once, crisis meant a critical or decisive stage in a course of events—a day of judgment—that must lead to a resolution. A crisis in an illness, for example, was the moment at which a definitive turn toward life or death, improvement or worsening could be expected…Our world is in perpetual crisis, a crisis that never resolves, “no crisis at all,” because resolving it would end the game. Crisis is “our normal state,” the consequence of never allowing a final judgment to be reached.

Agamben, in an address given in the cathedral of Notre Dame in Paris in 2009 in the presence of the bishop of Paris, spoke of “the Church’s incessant deferral of the Last Judgment” and “the eclipse of the messianic experience.” Establishments plan for their continuance, not their disruption. The Church, originally, and then the Law and the State act as what the New Testament calls “restrainers”—they hold back the moment at which the Messiah will appear, endlessly deferring this appearance along “the linear and homogeneous line of chronological time”—Macbeth'’s “tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow [which] creeps in this petty pace from day to day.”

Ivan Illich: an intellectual journey, by David Cayley
The Pennsylvania State University Press, 2021
Image description

Original X alt text

Agamben, in an address given in the cathedral of Notre Dame in Paris in 2009 in the presence of the bishop of Paris, spoke of “the Church’s incessant deferral of the Last Judgment” and “the eclipse of the messianic experience.” Establishments plan for their continuance, not their disruption. The Church, originally, and then the Law and the State act as what the New Testament calls “restrainers”—they hold back the moment at which the Messiah will appear, endlessly deferring this appearance along “the linear and homogeneous line of chronological time”—Macbeth'’s “tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow [which] creeps in this petty pace from day to day.” Ivan Illich: an intellectual journey, by David Cayley The Pennsylvania State University Press, 2021

Portrait of Giorgio Agamben
Image description

Original X alt text

Portrait of Giorgio Agamben

Frontspiece to a paper by Byron Bland of the Center of Strategic Arms Control titled, 'Marching and Rising: The Rituals of Small Differences and Great Violence.' With the quotation subhead: "What is really needed is the decommissioning of mind-sets in Northern Ireland." (Report of the International Body in Arms Decommissioning: The Mitchell Report, January 24, 1996)
Image description

Original X alt text

Frontspiece to a paper by Byron Bland of the Center of Strategic Arms Control titled, 'Marching and Rising: The Rituals of Small Differences and Great Violence.' With the quotation subhead: "What is really needed is the decommissioning of mind-sets in Northern Ireland." (Report of the International Body in Arms Decommissioning: The Mitchell Report, January 24, 1996)

Quoted or linked post

Nick Routledge@nick_routledge · 15 Jul 2022

@solarpunk_girl @alexevansuk 1/ Positive, grounded responses addressing those specific concerns are well in hand, frankly. Our primary challenge is a majoritarian sense of significance powerfully vested in dominant narratives, and the threat of personal salvation as apocalyptic as the doom that hounds us.

View this post’s context →

Context in the archive

Quoted by@johnrobb “The crises become “states of permanent exception and emergency,” and a permanent state of exception is, of course, no longer exceptional. Crisis is "our normal state", crisis that never resolves, “no crisis at all”. Why? Because resolving it would end the game.Quoted by@lukeburgis @NOV1TATE Someone, somewhere, I can't recall who, (Michael Kirwan SJ in a speech?) pointed emphatically at the paper by Byron Bland of the Center of Strategic Arms Control titled, 'Marching and Rising: The Rituals of Small Differences and Great Violence.'Quoted by@alastairmci @WaltBrueggemann Brueggemann, on it, always. Compare Blake: “The Religions of all Nations are derived from each Nation’s different reception of the Poetic Genius, which is every where call’d the Spirit of Prophecy.” The poet as miracle worker, not of the last word, but the first, opening the way.Quoted by@Eirikvi "And you are not the guide of the blind out of their error; you cannot make anyone hear but those who believe in our signs and have submitted." - 30:53 Quran. "And we never sent a warner to a community but its affluent members say, ‘We reject what you were sent with.’ ” Q 34:34.Quoted by@Andrew__Roth end/ Which brings us to the dirt under the fingernails of these, my transmitting fingers, uniting us all, root and branch, flesh and blood, off-screen and on-screen, in the dynamic interplay of a single helix of Presence. It is time, friends. "Eternity utters a day." - Heschel