Nick Routledge@nick_routledge
Reply to @nick_routledge

6/ You? You're in a moment where action matters. That’s where the messianism is - seizing the #now to #InterruptHistory. #MessianicExperience? It never comes by waiting. It has to be enacted and its moment is only ever #now. #NewWorldCreation

Quoted or linked post

Nick Routledge@nick_routledge · 16 Feb 2025

@trippfuller 7/ Benjamin decried passive messianism's waiting around, insisting that each generation must strive to exert its own 'messianic power' to bring justice to the world and the oppressed of the past. Redemption, he said, is a collective revolutionary task, performed in the present.

Copy of tweets here:

Including image of Erich Fromm’s You Shall Be As Gods, Page 113

Aside from the opposing views that catastrophe or growing enlightenment, respectively, will bring about re- demption, a third one holds that both possibilities exist. Thus R. Yohanan taught: "The son of David [messiah] will come only in a generation that is either altogether righteous or altogether wicked" (Sanhedrin 98a). This statement emphasizes the radical nature of the views concerning the coming of the messiah. The improvement of man is not enough. He must either have achieved full humanity or he must have lost himself completely, and thus be ready for a full "return."
Image description

Original X alt text

Copy of tweets here: Including image of Erich Fromm’s You Shall Be As Gods, Page 113 Aside from the opposing views that catastrophe or growing enlightenment, respectively, will bring about re- demption, a third one holds that both possibilities exist. Thus R. Yohanan taught: "The son of David [messiah] will come only in a generation that is either altogether righteous or altogether wicked" (Sanhedrin 98a). This statement emphasizes the radical nature of the views concerning the coming of the messiah. The improvement of man is not enough. He must either have achieved full humanity or he must have lost himself completely, and thus be ready for a full "return."

Copy of tweet here:
Image description

Original X alt text

Copy of tweet here:

Extended description

Pictured speaker / quoted attribution: Catherine Keller Recovered pictured passage; not a claim to the full source. Passage boundary: Source: archive.nickroutledge.org/post/1891148338214392165 Preserve quoted-author distinctions; the containing tweet does not confer authorship. then our oikos (home) is abandoned Retained uncertainty: [{"passage": "Faint first line preceding ‘When salvation…’", "reason": "Image starts mid-sentence ‘of nature from which the earth now needs saving.’ Complete preceding clause not pictured or saved; visible fragment recovered."}]

Open original document

Extended description

Pictured speaker / quoted attribution: Catherine Keller, citation Recovered pictured passage; not a claim to the full source. Passage boundary: Source: archive.nickroutledge.org/post/1891148338214392165 Preserve quoted-author distinctions; the containing tweet does not confer authorship. Catherine Keller: Eschatology, Ecology and a Green Ecumenacy Journal for the Study of Religion, Nature and Culture, Issue 2 Jan. 1997 Retained uncertainty: [{"passage": "Faint first line preceding ‘When salvation…’", "reason": "Image starts mid-sentence ‘of nature from which the earth now needs saving.’ Complete preceding clause not pictured or saved; visible fragment recovered."}]

Open original document

Extended description

Pictured speaker / quoted attribution: Catherine Keller, faint preceding fragment Recovered pictured passage; not a claim to the full source. Passage boundary: Source: archive.nickroutledge.org/post/1891148338214392165 Preserve quoted-author distinctions; the containing tweet does not confer authorship. of nature from which the earth now needs saving. Retained uncertainty: [{"passage": "Faint first line preceding ‘When salvation…’", "reason": "Image starts mid-sentence ‘of nature from which the earth now needs saving.’ Complete preceding clause not pictured or saved; visible fragment recovered."}]

Open original document

Extended description

Pictured speaker / quoted attribution: Nick Saved source record associated with pictured writing; full saved record, not an exact pictured excerpt. Passage boundary: Source: archive.nickroutledge.org/post/1849550677590278419 Preserve quoted-author distinctions; the containing tweet does not confer authorship. @AimeTim 2/ Ultimately, praying isn't enough. Only so far as we actively participate in the radical indigeneity of a form of hope whereby we and the world neighbor one another, do we truly come home to the Resurrection Body of our salvation. Homemaking as homecoming, with better weather. t.co/K2jTzNPLd9 Retained uncertainty: [{"passage": "Faint first line preceding ‘When salvation…’", "reason": "Image starts mid-sentence ‘of nature from which the earth now needs saving.’ Complete preceding clause not pictured or saved; visible fragment recovered."}]

Open original document

Extended description

Pictured speaker / quoted attribution: Nick quoting Gutiérrez and Castillo; Catherine Keller quote Saved source record associated with pictured writing; full saved record, not an exact pictured excerpt. Passage boundary: Source: Preserve quoted-author distinctions; the containing tweet does not confer authorship. to @brianmclaren 2/ Gutiérrez: "The preferential options for the earth and the poor are inseparable from each other.” Castillo: “To be understood as central to Christian reflection and action, the relationship between these concerns and the mystery of salvation must be made evident." When salvation means removal from the earth to a heavenly home, then our home is abandoned to the assaults of those whose ultimate concern is neither heaven nor earth, but the power and wealth of their particular households. These households drain heaven and earth of what used to be called their “glory” - their energy, their beauty, their disclosiveness, and their adequacy to the needs of the whole. This makes for lousy weather. Catherine Keller I was much taken by your observation, "Hope is born when love goes to work," as a corollary to Gibran: "Work is love made visible." I'm curious if you're alert to the 'messianic-hope-come-to-ground' enfleshed in America's prophetic earthwork movement? Retained uncertainty: [{"passage": "Faint first line preceding ‘When salvation…’", "reason": "Image starts mid-sentence ‘of nature from which the earth now needs saving.’ Complete preceding clause not pictured or saved; visible fragment recovered."}]

Open original document

Extended description

Pictured speaker / quoted attribution: Nick quoting Norman Wirzba and Gibran Saved source record associated with pictured writing; full saved record, not an exact pictured excerpt. Passage boundary: Source: archive.nickroutledge.org/post/1891148338214392165 Preserve quoted-author distinctions; the containing tweet does not confer authorship. Beautifully stated, Norman. I was much taken by your observation, "Hope is born when love goes to work," as a corollary to Gibran: "Work is love made visible." I'm curious if you're alert to the 'messianic-hope-come-to-ground' enfleshed in America's prophetic earthwork movement? Hence, the anthropogenic dynamism of New World Creation - the deep ecology of peacemaking effecting and requiring an integral, intra-realm response to a symbiotic eco-cultural challenge. Jim Wallis: "Jesus didn’t say, “Blessed are the peace-lovers.” He said, “peace-makers". Day Six. New World Creation as the arc of the moral universe bending irrevocably towards the dynamic reconciliation of path, justice and peace? Prophetic earthwork secures the teleology in the natural, immediate sequence of a concrete, native journey into Beauty’s deepest ground. Retained uncertainty: [{"passage": "Faint first line preceding ‘When salvation…’", "reason": "Image starts mid-sentence ‘of nature from which the earth now needs saving.’ Complete preceding clause not pictured or saved; visible fragment recovered."}]

Open original document
View this post’s context →

Context in the archive

Quoted by@PageauJonathan 10/ Such figures prefigure the incarnational Kingdom—not a regime or utopia, but the arrival of the Real into history. It does not follow the arc of the world; it punctures it. And this rupture must be borne—not by one, but by many who embody the wound of the world remade.Quoted by10/ The signs we seek are already here. We scroll past Gaza, look for angels but not at the poor, wait for trumpets—while the Spirit groans in tongues we will not hear. Still, the fire burns on.